Wednesday, May 16, 2012

Politics & Violence


Yanomamo Revenge Killing 




The Yanomamo do not have a formal written language, number system or laws unlike many western cultures. In western society's we depend on the law and judicial system to bring justice to criminals. The Yanaomamo only have general rules and customs that are violated regularly.


Revenge killings in Yanomamo populations is usually blamed on "woman" meaning they are the original cause for animosity, be it through infidelity, failure to give a promised girl and in some cases rape. In the event that a brawl gets out of hand the family of the deceased may seek revenge on the kin of the victor. The resulting fights and warfare often result in many lost lives on both sides.

In the Yanomamo population the unokais are men who have killed another person and have gone through the unokaimou ceremony. There are a few benefits to becoming a unokai. Only the unokais can become patas (headman or leaders) of their village. The unokais are only more desirable as mates and often have more children because of this. A non-unokais is a man who has not shed any blood, however to the Yamomamo this is often seen as weak and they are ridiculed because of it. Being a unokai is a sign of power and strength in their community, any man seeking power or leadership would need to have gone through this ceremony.

Without warfare there would be no use for political structure, someone to decide when and who the next raid with affect. Leadership is often determined by kinship and unokais status. As I mentioned a pata can often have as many a dozen wives resulting in a great deal of offspring and a larger descent line.

If a raid occurs and is successful a tribe is expected to seek revenge on them, if they do not their status in other villages will be seen as week and cowardly. All of the headsman are unokai, the revenge killings will place these, men in higher social positions. 


Often revenge killings are determined by the deceased kin. Any given tribe can have multiple patas (headman or leaders) whom can have many as many as a dozen wives. In turn the chances of any revenge victim have many kin is quite high. The family or kin of the deceased will feel the need for revenge killings.

Men that participate in revenge killings are likely to be more attractive to the women in the village as well. The article shows that the unokais have a much higher reproduction rate compared to non-unokais. Wives are often obtained by force or arranged marriages, yet the woman in the village are more attracted to the unokais.

As shown by the Yamomamo revenge is very powerful and a person can become consumed by it, even if they "know" right from wrong. We often see in western trials and portrayed on popular television shows the motives behind killings; jealousy, infidelity, self-defense, power or even money. Often times an accused murderer is not a serial killer, it is a person who reacted in a violent manner during the heat of the moment. We fell the need for punishment and redemption against murder and in order to do that we have laws, courts, fair trial and prison for consequences. 


By Andrea Garrison


3 comments:

  1. Good initial discussion.

    I'm curious about this line: "Without warfare there would be no use for political structure, someone to decide when and who the next raid with affect."

    Is that the sole role of the headman of the Yanomamo? That may have been the central role discussed in this article, but is that all he does?

    Great job pulling out the underlying causes of killing and how they don't have to be pathological but much like the reasons behind the revenge killings of the Yanomamo. Our laws prevent us from reacting as the Yanomamo do when faced with violence in our own society.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great post, I really enjoyed reading it. I think you did a great job of covering all the topics and you did so in a logical but instructive way. I found the end of your post the most interesting. Most murders tried are not serial killers but average people caught up in the heat of the moment. That really made me compare our murderers her to revenge killings. Even though revenge killings are out of anger and for revenge I don't feel that in our culture with out laws they would be able to get anyone to believe that they were caught in the heat of the moment. I would think most would think premeditated murder since they can walk as far as 4 days and there are a group of them.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The sole role of the headsman probably isn't to oversee revenge killings, but I would go as far as saying that seems to be one of his primary responsibility's based on the article. The headsman also has many wives, children and a village to oversee. But to earn respect from his village and his neighbors, he must take part in many killings.

    ReplyDelete